David B. Reath, MD
Knoxville, TN (865) 450-9253
HKB Knoxville Staff

Celebrity Plastic Surgery: Why Angelina Jolie Is Not Heidi Montag

Angelina Jolie Plastic Surgery

One of the biggest news items this week has been the revelation, shared by Angelina Jolie, that she had undergone prophylactic mastectomies and reconstruction due to her high risks of developing breast cancer. From where I sit, her sharing of her story was open, honest, and-well- courageous. But it surprised me that in some of the press coverage, there are some very negative comments about what she has done and/or how she has shared this.

So, here’s the question: Is it a good thing or a bad thing when celebrities talk about plastic surgery, or more specifically, their own plastic surgery? Here’s what I think….

As in all things, there is no absolute answer. It really depends upon the circumstances, and the way in which the story is told. On one extreme we might find someone like Heidi Montag. Now, let me pause for a second and assure you that that I am normally opposed to talking about celebrities when they have plastic surgery. But Heidi was so public about what she did, that I feel comfortable about discussing what she had done in this context.

Angelina Jolie is Not Heidi Montag
In 2009 Heidi was very vocal about the ten plastic surgeries she had done at one time. Many of us who do plastic surgery for a living really questioned the reasonableness of what she was doing, and the thinking of her plastic surgeon (who, later, tragically died in a car crash). If there is one word that would describe Heidi’s revelation about her surgeries it would be: sensational (and I don’t mean this in the best sense of the word). The motivation had to be to garner as much attention for herself about the cosmetic surgery she has had done.

The key words here are: cosmetic surgery, personal attention, and sensational.

What Angelina Jolie has done and how she has done it are polar opposites. Women, like Angelina, who do carry the gene for breast cancer (BRAC1) have an 80% risk of having breast cancer by age 90. For many, this extremely high risk of a potential deadly disease is reason enough for treatment to prevent this. Treatment that in other circumstances may seem quite drastic. It is a very difficult and emotional decision for a woman to elect to have both her “normal” breasts removed and have them reconstructed. But if this lowers the risk of breast cancer to almost zero, it can be a good decision.

Because of the difficulty of such a decision, and at the same time the tremendous health benefit of such a decision, women who can talk about this can be a great resource to other women who may one day find themselves in the same situation. The way in which Ms. Jolie has told her story has allowed people to understand what this is really all about. There is no doctor speak from her. Just a story told in a way that all could understand.  The effect is one of educating people and sharing the experience about a prophylactic cancer treatment and its reconstructive, plastic surgery options.

interestingly, Angelina chose to not share her story or her journey until it was, for the most part, completed. Not only did this allow her and her family more privacy, but it tends to be less “sensational” when presented as a fait accompli.

So the key words here are: education, shared experience, and reconstructive surgery.

You can probably see where I am going here. Celebrities talking about cosmetic surgery is fraught with potential problems. While I agree with the absolute benefit of cosmetic surgery done on the right people for the right reasons, it is still a very personal – and for the most part, private – decision. When spoken about publicly, it should be done with the same “class” as Angelina’s story was told. I was recently involved with a story about a patient undergoing an arm lift. Our goal was to make the public aware of this as an option for people who might choose to do this, and to explain why more people were choosing this as an option. I think and hope we took the high road here.

Reconstructive surgery, while equally personal, may at times be easier to speak about publicly. With reconstruction we are repairing defects caused by trauma, cancer surgery, and birth defects to name a few, in order to restore a normal appearance and function.  Few people go out of their way to need such surgery. In most cases it is not elective. So, talking about these operations in a way that will help other people who may one day be in a position to need them, can be very good and very helpful.

Education: Good; Sensationalism: Bad
This, I believe, is what Angelina has done, and what Heidi did not do. When celebrities are talking about their plastic surgery with the intent of informing the public, and drawing attention to the surgery itself and not themselves, this can be very good. But if the talk about their plastic surgery is sensational and aimed at getting them on the front pages of the tabloids, this is not good at all.

On a final note, I was very sorry to hear criticism of what Angelina has done (and written), particularly by other women. I do not think that she implied that this is what all women should do. But by having the courage to speak about this honestly, without the desire to be in the spotlight (any more than she is already), she has been of help to many women who may face the same decision.

I wish Ms. Jolie and her family all the best as they live their lives together. And, I sincerely thank her for telling her story.

All the best,

Dr. David B. Reath




David B. Reath, MD


Cover Credit: Photograph by Melodie McDaniel / Trunk Archive

Leave a Reply

Fields marked with * are required.

Back to top

Contact Us Today.

Fields marked * are required

Terms of Use*
By checking the box on the contact form, you agree to the Terms of Use listed here: Communications through our website or via email are not encrypted and are not necessarily secure. Use of the internet or email is for your convenience only, and by using them, you assume the risk of unauthorized use. By checking this box you hereby agree to hold HKB Knoxville Cosmetic Surgery, its doctors and affiliates, harmless from any hacking or any other unauthorized use of your personal information by outside parties.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.